The Word from the Experts
DECEMBER 28, 1998:
We collected picks and descriptions from winebuyers at Fielding's, Reuben's, the
Austin Wine Merchant, and Wiggy's. Wines that were specifically recommended by more
than one store are noted as such. A store not being listed after a description does
not necessarily mean that a wine isn't available at the other stores.
Sparkling Wines Under $10
François Montand (around $8) A methode traditionelle blanc de blanc brut
(made from 100% Chardonnay) which is characteristically light and clean with some
toasty notes. Paul from Wiggy's says, "After two or three glasses of some cheap
Champagne, you'll have heartburn. Not with this one." (recommended by Reuben's,
Fielding's, Wiggy's)
Gratien and Meyer Brut Fleur de Lys (normally $12, now about $10) From a firm
that has been in business for 130 years. Lots of limestone in the soil helps give
these methode traditionelle wines deep flavor; a lot of character for 10 bills. Aromatic
hinting of apples, toast, nuts, with a delicate and persistent sparkle. (recommended
by Austin Wine Merchant)
Cristalino Spanish Cava (just under $10) Wiggy's winebuyer says, "We recommend
this because of the price point - it's got good acid, it's citrus-y and mineral-y,
with a lot of peachy flavors, but it's still sort of toasty, too. All in all, a lot
of character for that price range." (recommended by Wiggy's)
Sparkling Wines Under $20
Argyle Willamette Valley Brut, Oregon ("Normally a $20 bottle, we're running
it at $14.99.") "This wine, which is aged on its lees for a minimum of
three years, is disgorged on demand. Young, robust, full and rich on the palate,
this wine is just beginning to flex its considerable muscle - powerful good bubbles!
Made in the methode Champenoise by Rollin Soles, a Texas Aggie," says John Rennick
from Austin Wine Merchant. (recommended by Austin Wine Merchant, Wiggy's)
Roederer California Estate Brut "Stylistically in the same vein as its French
big brother (see Under $30 category), but the fruits are a little cleaner,
and it's a little less toasty. Very typically Californian, really well-made, nice
crisp flavors," says Rob Moshein of Reuben's. According to Paul McDonald, it's
a favorite under-$20 pick at Reuben's, too. "Good fruit - on the acid side,
but with a lot of power behind it." (recommended by Reuben's, Fielding's, Wiggy's)
Sparkling Wines Under $30
Roederer Brut Premier Champagne: ($26.99 for the holiday) This has light yeast,
warm toast, balanced fruit, and a very delicate sparkle - a classic French Champagne!
(recommended by Reuben's)
Alfred Gratien Brut Champagne (down from $31.99 for the season) This yeasty, toasty,
buttery, nutty Champagne is giving Clicquot a run for its money! (recommended by
Wiggy's)
Perrier-Jouët Grand Brut Champagne ("A steal at $23.75!") A blast
of pleasing yeast at the outset. Lemony without being creamy, with a really tight
bubble. Sort of glossy. "There's a lot of good Champagne out there but this
consistently makes our clients happy." (recommended by Austin Wine Merchant)
Montaudon Brut Champagne ($24.99) "This has got a balance I really like.
Sort of a doughy taste, but nutty. Comes alive in your mouth!" (recommended
by Fielding's)
Sparkling Wines Over $30
Clicquot Vintage Réserve 1989 ($42.50) Robb Walsh's new favorite. Golden-colored,
toasty, nutty-flavored glory. (recommended by Austin Wine Merchant)
Feuillatte Cuvée Palme D'Or 1990 ($99.99) Those at our tasting who rated
this wine highly found it complex and nutty like marzipan. Full-bodied and citrus-y
with excellent bubbles. (recommended by Reuben's, Austin Wine and Spirits)
L'Ermitage Brut 1992 ($30.99) Really elegant for an American sparkling wine. You
mix that with real Champagne, and people have a hard time sorting it out. (Fielding's)
Charles Heidseick Vintage Brut 1990 ($59.99) At 97 points, the highest rated sparkling
wine from the Wine Spectator "Top 100 at a Glance" list. According
to Rob Moshein from Reuben's, "It's worth $50 because it's a good combination
of the toasty, yeasty flavors with good fruit, wonderful texture, and very fine sparkle."
(recommended by Austin Wine Merchant)
Gratien and Meyer Cuvée Paradis ($77.99) "This is what I would recommend
for something over $50. In the style of a well-balanced luxury cuvée for under
$100, this is from Epernay in the Champagne district, but it hasn't reached the whole
world in the same way as Grande Dame, so the demand hasn't pushed the price over
the top yet. Complex aromas, lively, vibrant, citrus-y fruits, with a really long
finish," says Christian Primeaux. (recommended by Wiggy's)

|