Failing to Fail
APS Social Promotion Policy Fails Kids
By Cap'n O
OCTOBER 6, 1997:
Failure can be devastating. I was delirious with depression upon
learning that I wasn't good enough to be a bomber pilot. It was
crushing to know that never would I realize my most cherished
dream of being able to set whole cities on fire.
Failure can also be a blessing. Rejection caused me to intensify
my efforts at self-improvement. As a result, I achieved a degree
of success that undoubtedly sets the world's mouth agape. I landed
this job.
It's good, though, that I was told I didn't have the skills to
become a bomber pilot. Had I, with inadequate skills, been promoted
along, it would have been a national disaster. I might have mistakenly
bombed our own cities and, worse, destroyed shopping malls and
factory outlet centers, thus depriving Americans of their national
pasttime--buying stuff.
Albuquerque has a disaster of even greater magnitude. It's been
going on for years, and it needs to stop. The public schools have
a policy called "social promotion," whereby students
who have not learned the stuff necessary to get to the next grade--it
used to be called flunking--are promoted anyway. A teacher who
thinks a kid needs to repeat a grade can't flunk the student without
permission from the dunce's parents. Every year, kids who can't
read, write, add or subtract are passed on to the next grade because
their stupid parents won't let them be held back.
I know one kid who got to fourth grade without being able to read.
Her mother refused to let the schools make the kid repeat a grade
because she thought it would embarrass the kid. This dimly-lit
parent apparently couldn't figure that it's embarrassing and harmful
to a kid to be unable to read or write.
This idiotic policy guarantees that many of the people who graduate
from Albuquerque Public Schools won't have the skills necessary
to function as contributing members of society. The danger to
society is apparent and immense. We're graduating illiterates
who can't read maps, balance a checkbook or read the instructions
on love enhancement devices. We have pouting young people who
can't even spell the name of their gangs. Why do you think that
gang graffiti is so unintelligible? The little morons can't spell.
And you know that the parents who won't let their kids
be flunked are the ones who are out at night boozing, drugging
and dancing when they should be at home sitting on the couch helping
their kids figure out how to read, do math and tell time.
This "social promotion" policy is a reprehensible disgrace.
You wouldn't want an electrician who flunked every electricity
course but was given a license anyway to wire your house. If that
happened and you discovered that the dimwit didn't know an outlet
from a spigot but was still given a license, you'd be mad as hell
and would sue somebody. You would find the situation unacceptable.
If our trade schools churned out carpenters who built houses that
fell down, we'd be outraged. If you were operated on by a surgeon
who never should have passed anatomy class and who mistook your
heart for a burst appendix, your heirs would probably be appalled.
Especially if they didn't get a big court judgment. Imagine the
dire health consequences if we had waitresses who spelled "oatmeal,"
e-g-g-s. Or consider all the rotted livers that would result if
our bars were tended by bartending school graduates, who, when
asked for a shot and a beer, put the hard stuff in the big glass.
If our schools kept promoting people who flunked ethics classes,
we'd have to enlarge Congress.
APS "social promotion" policy doesn't promote anything
but ignorance and social disaster. It should be eliminated. For
when you fail to fail a kid who is flunking, you fail the kid.
But there's still hope for public school students who graduate
without learning anything to attain lucrative positions in this
community. They can get jobs as APS administrators.
--Cap'n O
|