Call of the Wild
By Debbie Gilbert & Leonard Gill
The Return of the Wolf to
Yellowstone
by Thomas McNamee
Henry Holt & Co., 354 pp., $27.50
AUGUST 18, 1997:
In 1926, the last native
wolf was shot in Yellowstone National Park. During the seven
decades that followed, conservationists came to believe that
something was wrong with this picture -- that the Greater
Yellowstone Ecosystem could never be considered complete until
its major predator, Canis lupus, was again part of the
equation. After one of the most bitterly fought environmental
battles of this century, advocates of the wolf successfully
returned the much-maligned carnivore to Yellowstone in 1995.
As told by former
Memphian Thomas McNamee, the tale of the wolf's reintroduction
becomes an epic clash of values between those who admire wolves
and those -- mainly cattle ranchers and right-wing Western
politicians -- who don't. Numerous public hearings and court
proceedings fail to show a valid reason not to bring back
the wolf, so the unprecedented experiment is given the green
light.
It seems simple enough: Capture three
packs of wolves in Alberta, Canada (where the species is still
abundant), transport them to Yellowstone, and turn them loose.
But this undertaking is much more complex than it first appears.
The wolves' presence will have a profound impact on every aspect
of the ecosystem -- not to mention legal, ethical, financial, and
political implications that stretch far beyond the boundaries of
Yellowstone.
Moreover, the wolves are a wild card; no
one can predict just what they'll do in their new surroundings.
When most of the wolves seem to be heading north, out of the
park, the wolf-recovery team begins to despair. What if the
animals are trying to return to their birthplace, thereby
negating the entire project?
McNamee was given near-exclusive access
to the researchers and government workers on the team, and he
paints vivid portraits of each member, allowing us to know them
as people. Their dedication to the effort is total; their spirits
soar and plummet in response to each small victory and setback.
And their work is complicated by grating uncertainty, because
imprecise radio-collar tracking is often their only means of
knowing the wolves' whereabouts.
And then something goes horribly wrong.
A senseless crime -- which McNamee describes in nightmarish
detail -- turns the wildlife-management project into a hunt for a
cold-blooded killer.
Without slowing the pace of the story
too much, McNamee weaves in his own musings on the nature of
wilderness and our relationship to its inhabitants. In one
chapter he reminisces about growing up in Whitehaven in the
1950s, recalling how the wild places gradually were supplanted by
subdivisions. This seeming digression serves a purpose -- it
illustrates why wilderness matters, whether in Memphis or in
Montana.
Movingly written and factually
impeccable, The Return of the Wolf to Yellowstone
qualifies as one of best environmental books of the decade. -- Debbie
Gilbert
The Wild Child: The Unsolved
Mystery of Kaspar Hauser
By Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson
Free Press, 247 pp., $13 (paper)
In the more than 150 years since his
death, Kaspar Hauser has haunted the imaginations of no less a
lineup than Verlaine, Melville, and Rilke (and more recently, the
lesser likes of filmmaker Werner Herzog and songwriter Suzanne
Vega). Who, then, if you don't know, was this Kaspar Hauser?
If he was, strictly speaking, not a
"wolf-child," worse perhaps was done to him than to be
raised by wolves: Hauser was held, from roughly the age of 4, in
a dungeon and accorded the barest human contact. Twelve years
later, in 1828, he showed up in the town of Nuremberg, Germany.
In 1829, an unknown assailant tried to cut his throat. And in
1833, the same or another unknown assailant lured him to a
deserted grove and stabbed him in the heart.
Was Kaspar Hauser the rightful and
terribly wronged heir to the principality of Baden -- as evidence
seemed to suggest even during his lifetime -- or was he a fraud?
What explained his astonishing progress in language? His
remarkable skills in drawing? His great compassion for all living
creatures? Was Kaspar Hauser the archetypal Romantic hero, man in
his natural state, a bona fide innocent? Or was he a dissembler
out to take advantage of well-wishing officials and a captivated
public?
Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson gives us fresh
translations of contemporary records (including Feuerbach's
classic account); endnotes almost as fascinating as his main
text; and appendices that range from the Nuremberg mayor's
initial proclamation to an essay on two wolf children thought to
have been discovered in India in 1920. Masson's own thoughts on
child abuse (and trashing of Freud on this issue) may seem mere
tags to his useful introductory remarks, but The Wild Child
is a necessary resource for anyone in need of an update on, or
introduction to, Kaspar Hauser's short, sad life. -- Leonard
Gill
|