THE OPENING SHOT of Shanghai Triad shows a little
boy waiting on a busy street corner, standing stock still amid
the chaos, observing the crowd patiently. The first time we see
the female lead, she's in a feathered costume with a chorus line
behind her, singing a song with lyrics that go, roughly paraphrased:
"Look at me, I'm really, really sexy." With this set
of images, Chinese director Zhang Yimou shows a rare talent to
establish the heart of a story with a few deft strokes, because
these are the relationships that remain essential throughout the
film: The little boy is a witness and the woman is the spectacle.
Shiusheng (Wang Xiao Xiao) is a kid from the provinces who comes
to the city to be a servant for his rich, distant cousin, a godfather
of one of the crime mobs that flourished in Shanghai in the 1930s.
He's assigned to wait on Xiao Jingbao (Gong Li), a surly nightclub
singer and the godfather's kept woman. Xiao Jingbao is all surface
glitz and style, with a fancy house and clothes provided by her
gangster sugar daddy--a pre-revolutionary material girl. Her new
servant is a complete hick--he's utterly baffled by a cigarette
lighter--and Xiao Jingbao relishes making fun of him. He, in turn,
hates her and spits in her tea. But the connection between them
grows as it becomes clear they're trapped together in a world
of violent, powerful men.
If Coppola had made this movie, or God forbid, Oliver Stone,
it would have slipped into the conventions of a crime story, with
masculine skirmishes over territory and tides of absolute power
corrupting absolutely. But Shanghai Triad concentrates
on the relationships between the characters, especially the characters
without power--namely, the women and children. The story is told
from the servant boy's point of view, and every scene is shown
through his eyes or has him in it. Shuisheng is inarticulate,
young, and maybe not too bright, but he sure is good at peeping
through cracked doors. From his innocent vantage point, we see
all the smoky, gilded debauchery of the crime lord's life. We
also see Shuisheng's growing affection for Xiao Jingbao, who turns
out to have a heart of gold under that glittery exterior, a point
that might have become Clichéd if it weren't for Gong Li's
subtle performance.
Xiao Jingbao also grows fond of her servant--he seems to
be the only person around who isn't using her. Together they're
whisked off to a remote island, ostensibly to flee attack from
a rival gang. In this, as in his earlier movies like Red Sorghum
and Raise the Red Lantern, Zhang Yimou is fascinated by
the subservient position of women in pre-revolutionary China.
They are pictured, with great compassion, as caged birds; complex
human beings who are regarded by men as mere pets. In Shanghai
Triad, it becomes increasingly clear that Xiao Jingbao is
caught in a web spun by dangerous men. She's not so much in hiding
on the island as imprisoned, and she is not so much a companion
as she is bait for the rival gang. To the men who keep Xiao Jingbao,
she's a lure or a prize or a pet. Only Shuisheng, who is himself
a bit of a lapdog, honestly cares about the person beneath her
glamorous exterior, the human being beneath the spectacle.
Shanghai Triad is a beautiful, intelligently composed
film. Zhang Yimou has a talent for sustaining visual metaphors
in an almost novelistic way. The scenes of gangster life in Shanghai
are bathed in gold, smoke and artificial light: It's a decadent,
superficial world where money is of supreme value. When they retreat
to the island, the film becomes washed in a calm, pale blue--even
Xiao Jingbao throws off her silks and puts on peasant garb--conveying
a sense of serenity and the value of simple things. Children and
peasants are often shown below the horizon, submerged in the land,
in an unforced metaphor for their harmony with nature and simple
desires, as opposed to the greed of the gangsters. In this portrayal
of peasants and children, Shanghai Triad shows the influence
of Indian filmmaker Satyajit Ray; in fact, some of the scenes
of children walking through fields of tall, feather-tipped grass
are strikingly reminiscent of Ray's sublime Pather Panchali.
If some of this has overtones of a Communist party line--good
peasants, corrupt capitalists--it might be because Zhang has to
run all his films by government censors. Nonetheless, this film
is made with such grace and feeling that it's as far from propaganda
as you can get.