Film editing used to be so hard. All those images, all those unruly
pieces that had to be fitted together just right, and for what? A dumb old
meaning. But now you too can build your own hyperkinetic critique of
a media-dazed society--simply by using the Oliver Stone Montage-O-Matic!
Just slap together the following elements: an actor (say, Jo Ann Worley); a
close-up of a body part (Jo Ann Worley's foot); a highway sign ("SLIPPERY
WHEN WET"); a loaded religious image (Moses smashing the Ten Commandments);
a scorpion (two, if they aren't all booked); and random stock footage (road
kill, ceiling fans, Ed Ames on the Tonight Show). Add splattery
filler and repeat every three minutes, and in no time you'll have Stone's
new movie U-Turn.
U-Turn isn't just a lousy movie; it's one of those colossal stinkbombs,
like Wild at Heart or Showgirls, that retroactively fouls a director's past
work. In Stone's last movie, Nixon, the Montage-O-Matic functioned as a
kind of celluloid sausage-grinder: The director shoved in showy cameos and
specious docudrama and hokey time-lapse photography, and the machine spat
out something much like sousemeat--a compression of unsavory ingredients
into an unspeakable whole. But Stone could at least argue that his style
was appropriate for Nixon, a public figure who was subjected to kinesthetic
media bombardment--just like the serial-killer celebrities of Natural Born
Killers and the trial-balloon conspiracies of JFK. No such claim holds for
U-Turn, which is set in a sleepy small town where nobody even appears to
own a TV. It's plainly not the country or the century that's suffering from
an attention deficit; it's the director.
The plot of U-Turn is almost identical to the sleeper Red Rock
West (and a dozen other noir thrillers before it): A stranger
gets stuck in a scrubby desert town, catches the eye of a mysterious femme
fatale, and soon winds up caught between her and her murderous husband. But
Stone doesn't care about the story's dull familiarity; he's too busy
changing film stocks and recycling other directors' leftover camera
tricks--a Spike Lee dolly, a Sam Raimi zoom--to work up a shred of interest
in the characters or the setting. The town seems to change size at whim; in
one scene, it appears to have a single, flyblown spaghetti-western street,
then it turns out to have a wealthy real-estate mogul and a half-dozen
candidates for public office.
Some of the actors do surprisingly fine work in the midst of this
nonsense: Sean Penn as the drifter antihero has a miserable why-me scowl
that gets funnier as the movie goes along, and he has a couple of hilarious
sparring matches with Billy Bob Thornton as a mush-mouthed menace of a
crooked mechanic. Jennifer Lopez makes an effectively elusive siren, and
Powers Boothe brings a quiet authority to his role as a sheriff. But
they're lucky: They haven't been tricked out in goofy List of Adrian
Messenger disguises, like Jon Voight's Halloween-costume Indian or Nick
Nolte's false teeth. (Between Nolte and Thornton, the movie succeeds as a
cautionary tale for proper dental care.)
Oliver Stone got his start working on low-budget horror movies and
exploitation flicks, and he reportedly loves them still: Last year he
executive-produced the savage little gem Freeway, a blood-soaked
rewrite of Little Red Riding Hood. But U-Turn has a
contemptuous feel, as if the director couldn't be bothered to focus his
energies on such a trifling story. It's such a mess that it's being
marketed now as a sort of ironic comedy, and about the 20th time you've
seen the boom microphone drop into the frame, you're tempted to believe it.
The editing is the biggest joke--especially when Sean Penn turns
black-and-white for no reason, or the moon hotfoots it across the sky for
the third time, or the director suddenly cuts (why not?) to an elaborate
stained-glass figure that bears no relevance to anything. In the past,
Stone seemed to be trying to subvert the fundamental principle of film
editing--that two images in juxtaposition create a separate meaning--but
now we see he was just trying to salvage every scrap of celluloid from the
cutting-room wastebasket. If nothing else, U-Turn proves that the
Montage-O-Matic is capable of mulching all the crap Oliver Stone can shovel
into it.