Scott Smith's grim suspense novel A Simple Plan may be the most
deftly plotted thriller I've ever read, a trip-wired package that poses an
Ethics 101 puzzler--if you find a bag of money in the forest, who has to
know?--in terms worthy of Edgar Allen Poe. Given the soundness of the
source material, the film version, directed by Sam Raimi from Smith's own
script, works like gangbusters just by showing up.
Here Bill Paxton plays the nice, conservative, dough-strapped family man
who finds the snow-covered wreckage of a plane containing $4.5 million in
cash. With his brother Jacob (Billy Bob Thornton) and his brother's
lunkhead buddy (Brent Briscoe) in tow, he hits upon a simple plan to keep
the cash. But money is never simple. In Smith's cunning morality play,
you're suckered into siding with the protagonist, who starts out doing the
right thing, then the only thing, then some very bad things. That
each new twist makes keen psychological sense only adds to the infernal
tension.
The wacky exuberance of director Raimi's Evil Dead movies is
nowhere in evidence, but the spare, pitiless style he displays here is
ideally suited to the material. His filmmaking has the lean tautness you
associate with killer B-movies: no wasted shots, just forward motion--not
to mention the most expressive use of icy devastation since Fargo.
Against all that blank white snow, every color leaves a stain like sin.
Paxton uses his deceptive average-Joe looks to great effect in a subtly
demanding role, but Billy Bob Thornton's homely, heartrending decency as
Jacob gives this clever chiller real weight--nobody suggests more depth of
feeling playing inarticulate characters. A Simple Plan views its
characters' greed and folly with the same cold eyes as the ravens that
hover over the crash site, waiting to feed on the remains.