Whatever else you can say about Good Will Hunting, it's
definitely the nicest, safest movie ever dedicated to the twin memories of
Allen Ginsberg and William S. Burroughs. In this likable but thoroughly
conventional drama, directed by Gus Van Sant from a script by actors Matt
Damon and Ben Affleck, Damon plays Will Hunting, a tough South Boston kid
who works as a janitor at MIT. Will's life away from work is a blur of bars
and brawls, spent mostly with his construction-worker chum Chuckie
(Affleck) and his pals from the neighborhood.
Like Will, they resent the professors and wealthy students who brush
past them on the streets. But they cherish a secret the blue bloods don't
know: Will is a mathematical genius, an unschooled prodigy with the natural
gifts of an Einstein. When three people discover the magnitude of his
ability--an egotistical math professor (Stellan SkarsgŒrd), a loving
student (Minnie Driver), and a grieving therapist (Robin Williams)--Will
has to choose whether to accept the burden of greatness or retreat to the
sheltered, unthreatening world of his buddies.
Brilliance is a tough subject for any movie: It's not easy to convey,
and harder still to make sympathetic or understandable to the vast majority
of us who aren't brilliant. All too often in movies, from The
Absent-Minded Professor through Shine, genius is merely equated
with harmless eccentricity. So Will's mean streak in the early scenes is a
pleasant surprise. As generous as his gifts are, Will isn't above using
them sadistically: He zeroes in on people and glibly dispatches them, like
a gunslinger--or like the rich phonies he delights in skewering in bars. At
first Will's quick temper seems bound to his quick wit, and we're
fascinated to see how deeply the two connect.
Not very, as it turns out. Good Will Hunting never suggests for a
moment that Will's anger has anything to do with being smarter than the
ordinary folk around him; that would ruin the salt-of-the-earth cool that
Damon and Affleck work so hard to provide him. He's no egghead--why, he
drinks beer and gets laid and kicks ass! Although the movie sets up Will's
class resentment as a character failing--he's rotten to his wealthy
girlfriend and disdainful of professors--there's never an indication that
the filmmakers don't share it, or won't exploit it for all it's worth.
(Apparently, Will only gets impatient with rich people.) At the same time,
Good Will Hunting turns into yet another story about teaching
humility to a cocky kid, as if brilliant people aren't complete until
they're made nice. We might as well be watching Tom Cruise learn the value
of teamwork by saving the Iceman.
As he demonstrated by pumping some feeling and cinematic savvy into Buck
Henry's coarse, obvious screenplay for To Die For, Gus Van Sant is
the best friend a weak script ever had: He's a wizard at honing in on the
nuances of performance and location that can bring freshness to trite
situations. The icky platitudes the therapist exchanges with Will would be
insufferable if not for Van Sant's rapt, hype-free concentration on the
rapport between Robin Williams (who's remarkably good) and Matt Damon
(who's impressively intense but sometimes sounds as if he's reciting
speeches instead of thinking on his feet). And while Good Will
Hunting is at heart a boy's movie--Minnie Driver's character is
executive producer Kevin Smith's idea of a dream woman, a girl who likes to
say "blowjob" and drink beer with the fellas--there's no denying Van Sant's
charming evocation of brotherly camaraderie, the tang of the wise-guy
dialogue, or the wonderful ease Damon and Affleck show in their scenes
together.
But even Van Sant succumbs to visual clichs, depicting Will's isolation
with a ride in an empty elevated-train car. After the astounding early
promise of Drugstore Cowboy and My Own Private Idaho, and the
hipper-than-thou calamity of Even Cowgirls Get the Blues, Gus Van
Sant is turning into an expert mainstream director who perfectly serves the
needs of a script. That's great; I just wish he'd serve better scripts.
It's too early in his career for him to show this much affinity for a story
about a genius in danger of squandering his talents.