Excess Baggage

Nashville Scene

DIRECTED BY: Marco Brambilla

REVIEWED: 09-08-97

Few movies this summer have had a plot as ordinary, writing as clichd, and characters as forgettable as Excess Baggage. Tri-Star Pictures acknowledged as much when they neglected to schedule advance screenings for critics. So why did I spend half the movie with an uncontrollable idiot grin plastered on my face? Because of Benicio Del Toro, the year's most unlikely romantic lead, who turns this straight-to-video fodder into a quirkfest worthy of cult status. Connoisseurs of acting have treasured every second of Del Toro's appearances in The Funeral, Basquiat, and The Usual Suspects; now we get a whole movie's worth, and he doesn't disappoint.

Neither does Alicia Silverstone, who stars as poor little rich girl Emily T. Hope (and who, as executive producer, made the decision to cast Del Toro). Nor does Christopher Walken as her protector, Uncle Ray. It's a shame the movie around them is such a shambles. Emily's magnate father pays no attention to her, so she fakes her own kidnapping, which goes awry when Vincent (Del Toro) steals her Beemer. Vincent owes the chief of the car-theft ring (Harry Connick Jr.) $200 grand, Uncle Ray is about to blow his cover, and Emily won't cooperate. It's such a typical romantic caper plot that we're going to see it again soon in A Life Less Ordinary. Likewise, there's nothing imaginative about the script by Max D. Adams or the direction by Marco Brambilla. The supposedly comic fights look like they were filmed by someone who had heard about slapstick but had never actually seen any.

Apparently, all the imagination went into the casting. Silverstone can still charm even with no material, and she fearlessly flouts every convention of hostagedom. Walken treats us to a sampling of his legendary talents, from quiet menace to full-throated song. And Del Toro is a true original; he underplays so deeply that when Silverstone kicks him in the groin, he barely moves. With his bizarre accent and mumbling delivery, he's only marginally understandable, and every few minutes he makes an unmotivated gesture. When Del Toro and Walken share the screen, fitful phrasings, non sequiturs, and unthinkable line readings reach a fever pitch. For those who love fine acting of the midnight-movie school, it's pure ecstasy.

If anyone has the guts to cast Del Toro in a leading role after this movie sinks into box-office oblivion, I'll be surprised. But I'm thinking of sending Alicia Silverstone a personal thank-you note for casting him this time. She's made one critic very, very happy.

--Donna Bowman

Full Length Reviews
Excess Baggage
Excess Baggage
Excess Baggage

Capsule Reviews
Excess Baggage

Film Vault Suggested Links
Runaway Bride
Blast from the Past
Lost and Found

Related Merchandise
Search for related videos at Reel.com
Search for more by Marco Brambilla at Reel.com
Search for related books at Amazon.com
Search for related music at Amazon.com

Rate this Film
If you don't want to vote on a film yet, and would like to know how others voted, leave the rating selection as "Vote Here" and then click the Cast Vote button.